| Draft Year | Player | Summer Team | College | MLB Team | Draft Round |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2009 | Barry Butera | Sag Harbor '08 | Boston College | Houston Astros | 21st |
| 2010 | Steve McQuail | Sag Harbor '08 | Canisius | Toronto Blue Jays | 30th |
| 2010 | Justin Echevarria | Riverhead '09 | Stony Brook | San Diego Padres | 40th |
| 2011 | Nick Ahmed | Westhampton '09 | UConn | Atlanta Braves | 2nd |
| 2011 | Kyle Kubitza | Southampton '09 | Texas State | Atlanta Braves | 3rd |
| 2011 | Nick Tropeano | Riverhead '09 | Stony Brook | Houston Astros | 5th |
| 2011 | Andrew Cain | North Fork '09 | UNC-Wilmington | Milwaukee Brewers | 12th |
| 2011 | Phil Klein | Sag Harbor '08 | Youngstown State | Texas Rangers | 30th |
| 2011 | Joel Thys | Sag Harbor '10 | Ohlone | Florida Marlins | 47th |
| 2012 | Paul Paez | Southampton '12 | Rio Hondo | New York Mets | 18th |
| 2012 | Alex Williams | Westhampton '10 | Louisiana Tech | Chicago White Sox | 19th |
| 2012 | Andrew Cain | North Fork '09 | UNC Wilmington | San Francisco Giants | 24th |
| 2012 | Brandon Kuter | Westhampton '10, '11 | George Mason | Texas Rangers | 29th |
| 2012 | Andrew Ferreira | Southampton '10 | Harvard | Minnesota Twins | 32nd |
| 2012 | Justin Topa | Southampton '10 | Long Island | Cincinnati Reds | 33rd |
| 2012 | Blake Amaral | Southampton '10 | Hawaii Pacific | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 40th |
| 2012 | Kevin Heller | Westhampton '10, '11 | Amherst | Boston Red Sox | 40th |
| 2013 | Stuart Turner | Southampton '11 | Ole Miss | Minnesota Twins | 3rd |
| 2013 | Jordan Patterson | Westhampton '11 | South Alabama | Colorado Rockies | 4th |
| 2013 | Aaron Slegers | Riverhead '11 | Indiana | Minnesota Twins | 5th |
| 2013 | Kyle McGowin | Sag Harbor '11, '12 | Savannah State | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 5th |
| 2013 | Zack Godley | Southampton '10 | Tennessee | Chicago Cubs | 10th |
| 2013 | James Lomangino | Westhampton '10 | St. John's | Oakland Athletics | 14th |
| 2013 | Kevin McCarthy | Sag Harbor '11 | Marist | Kansas City Royals | 16th |
| 2013 | Zach Mathieu | Riverhead '11 | Franklin Pierce | New York Mets | 16th |
| 2013 | Justin Topa | Southampton '10 | Long Island | Pittsburgh Pirates | 17th |
| 2013 | Frank Schwindel | Riverhead '11 | St. John's | Kansas City Royals | 18th |
| 2013 | Garrett Hughes | Southampton '10 | Stanford | San Francisco Giants | 19th |
| 2013 | Mike Ahmed | Westhampton '11 | Holy Cross | Los Angeles Dodgers | 20th |
| 2013 | Brenton Allen | Southampton '12 | UCLA | Washington Nationals | 20th |
| 2013 | Antonio Alvarez | Southampton '11 | Elon | Arizona Diamondbacks | 22nd |
| 2013 | Donnie Hart | Westhampton '10 | Texas State | Baltimore Orioles | 27th |
| 2013 | Kyle Lloyd | Westhampton '10 | Evansville | San Diego Padres | 29th |
| 2013 | Joel Thys | Sag Harbor '11 | Arizona Christian | Arizona Diamondbacks | 31st |
| 2013 | Max Watt | Center Moriches '13 | Hillsborough CC | Boston Red Sox | 37th |
| 2013 | Paul Paez | Southampton '12 | Rio Hondo | New York Mets | 38th |
| 2013 | Jack Cleary | Southampton '10 | Maryland | Milwaukee Brewers | 39th |
| 2014 | Mac James | Shelter Island '13 | Oklahoma | Tampa Bay Rays | 6th |
| 2014 | Kody Kerski | North Fork '11 | Sacred Heart | Seattle Mariners | 8th |
| 2014 | JB Kole | Southampton '12 | Villanova | Milwaukee Brewers | 8th |
| 2014 | Chris Pike | Southampton '11 | Oklahoma City | Tampa Bay Rays | 9th |
| 2014 | Ben Brewster | Sag Harbor '11 | Maryland | Chicago White Sox | 17th |
| 2014 | Steve Ascher | North Fork '12 | SUNY Oneonta | Tampa Bay Rays | 17th |
| 2014 | James Lomangino | Westhampton '10 | St. John's | Colorado Rockies | 18th |
| 2014 | Alec Sole | Riverhead '12 | Saint Louis | Tampa Bay Rays | 18th |
| 2014 | Jordan Parris | Riverhead '12 | Tennessee Tech | Colorado Rockies | 20th |
| 2014 | Jim Duff | Sag Harbor '12 | Stonehill | New York Mets | 20th |
| 2014 | Patrick Peterson | Southampton '12 | NC State | Seattle Mariners | 23rd |
| 2014 | Tyler Badamo | Center Moriches '12 | Dowling | New York Mets | 24th |
| 2014 | Brandon Thomas | Center Moriches '13 | San Diego State | Kansas City Royals | 24th |
| 2014 | Taylor Black | Westhampton '11 | Texas State | Colorado Rockies | 26th |
| 2014 | David Speer | Southampton '11 | Columbia | Cleveland Indians | 27th |
| 2014 | Brant Whiting | Southampton '11, '12 | Stanford | Los Angeles Dodgers | 30th |
| 2014 | Justin Hepner | North Fork '12 | San Diego State | Miami Marlins | 36th |
| 2014 | Eric Peterson | Southampton '12 | NC State | Houston Astros | 37th |
| 2014 | JJ Franco | Sag Harbor '11, '12, '13 | Brown | Atlanta Braves | 38th |
| 2015 | Seby Zavala | Riverhead '12 | San Diego State | Chicago White Sox | 12th |
| 2015 | Cody Stashak | Westhampton '14 | St. John's | Minnesota Twins | 13th |
| 2015 | Nick Dini | Center Moriches '12 | Wagner | Kansas City Royals | 14th |
| 2015 | Jerry Downs | Riverhead '13 | St. Thomas | Boston Red Sox | 15th |
| 2015 | Thomas Hackimer | North Fork '13 | St. John's | New York Mets | 15th |
| 2015 | Ryan McCormick | Southampton '13 | St. John's | Colorado Rockies | 16th |
| 2015 | Max Almonte | Southampton '12, '13 | Villanova | St. Louis Cardinals | 16th |
| 2015 | Joey Havrilak | Westhampton '13 | Akron | Detroit Tigers | 18th |
| 2015 | Kyle Miller | Montauk '14 | Florida Atlantic | Chicago Cubs | 19th |
| 2015 | Rob Fonseca | Southampton '12 | Northeastern | Seattle Mariners | 21st |
| 2015 | Max Watt | Center Moriches '13, Shelter Island '14 | Lynn | Boston Red Sox | 22nd |
| 2015 | Danny Mendick | Riverhead '14 | UMass Lowell | Chicago White Sox | 22nd |
| 2015 | Cody Carroll | Center Moriches '12 | Southern Miss | New York Yankees | 22nd |
| 2015 | Alex Perez | North Fork '12 | Virginia Tech | Minnesota Twins | 23rd |
| 2015 | Jacob Bodner | Sag Harbor '12, '13 | Xavier | Kansas City Royals | 27th |
| 2015 | Stuart Levy | Sag Harbor '12 | Arkansas State | Baltimore Orioles | 27th |
| 2015 | Alex Katz | Shelter Island '13 | St. John's | Chicago White Sox | 27th |
| 2015 | Mike Wallace | Shelter Island '13 | Fairfield | Pittsburgh Pirates | 30th |
| 2015 | Brendan Butler | Center Moriches '13 | Dowling | Oakland Athletics | 30th |
| 2015 | Tim Ingram | Southampton '14 | SUNY Old Westbury | Tampa Bay Rays | 30th |
| 2015 | Dillon Persinger | Riverhead '15 | Golden West | Cleveland Indians | 31st |
| 2015 | Charles Galiano | Center Moriches '13 | Fordham | Milwaukee Brewers | 40th |
| 2016 | Corbin Burnes | Riverhead '14 | St. Mary's | Milwaukee Brewers | 4th |
| 2016 | Thomas Hackimer | North Fork '13 | St. John's | Minnesota Twins | 4th |
| 2016 | Stephen Woods | North Fork '14 | Albany | San Francisco Giants | 8th |
| 2016 | Stephen Ridings | Shelter Island '15 | Haverford | Chicago Cubs | 8th |
| 2016 | Sam Machonis | Shelter Island '13 | Florida Southern | Detroit Tigers | 10th |
| 2016 | Dan Rizzie | Sag Harbor '13, '14 | Xavier | New York Mets | 13th |
| 2016 | Chris Hall | Sag Harbor '13 | Elon | Toronto Blue Jays | 14th |
| 2016 | Andre Jernigan | Riverhead '13 | Xavier | Minnesota Twins | 14th |
| 2016 | Nick Heath | North Fork '13, '15 | Northwestern State | Kansas City Royals | 16th |
| 2016 | Will Savage | Shelter Island '14 | Columbia | Detroit Tigers | 16th |
| 2016 | Dillon Persinger | Riverhead '15 | Golden West | Los Angeles Dodgers | 17th |
| 2016 | Greg Weissert | Westhampton '14 | Fordham | New York Yankees | 18th |
| 2016 | Stefan Trosclair | Center Moriches '13 | Louisiana Lafayette | St. Louis Cardinals | 20th |
| 2016 | Brennan Morgan | Westhampton '13 | Kennesaw State | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 24th |
| 2016 | Charley Gould | Riverhead '13 | William & Mary | Oakland Athletics | 26th |
| 2016 | Jack Sundberg | Riverhead '13 | Connecticut | Washington Nationals | 26th |
| 2016 | Mike O'Reilly | Center Moriches '13 | Flagler | St. Louis Cardinals | 27th |
| 2016 | Ben Ruta | Southampton '13 | Wagner | New York Yankees | 30th |
| 2016 | Trevor Simms | Shelter Island '12, '13 | Tulane | Arizona Diamondbacks | 32nd |
| 2016 | Jonathon Mulford | Sag Harbor '13 | Adelphi | Milwaukee Brewers | 34th |
| 2016 | Ty Blankmeyer | Shelter Island '13 | St. John's | Cincinnati Reds | 36th |
| 2016 | Robert Galligan | North Fork '12 | Maryland | Arizona Diamondbacks | 36th |
| 2016 | Welby Malczewski | Westhampton '14 | Heartland CC | Arizona Diamondbacks | 37th |
| 2016 | Colin Brockhouse | Westhampton '15 | Ball State | Pittsburgh Pirates | 37th |
| 2017 | Collin Snider | Shelter Island '15 | Vanderbilt | Kansas City Royals | 12th |
| 2017 | Ricky Surum | Southampton '14 | Mount Olive | New York Yankees | 16th |
| 2017 | Chris Hess | Shelter Island '15 | Rhode Island | New York Yankees | 17th |
| 2017 | Dillon Persinger | Riverhead '15 | Cal State Fullerton | Cleveland Indians | 18th |
| 2017 | Joey Bartosic | Montauk '14 | George Washington | Colorado Rockies | 19th |
| 2017 | Jake Cousins | North Fork '14 | Penn | Washington Nationals | 20th |
| 2017 | Jared Finkel | Southampton '16 | Iona | Minnesota Twins | 23rd |
| 2017 | Matt Peacock | North Fork '13 | South Alabama | Arizona Diamondbacks | 23rd |
| 2017 | Colin Brockhouse | Westhampton '15 | Ball State | Toronto Blue Jays | 24th |
| 2017 | Matt McCann | Sag Harbor '15 | Fairleigh Dickinson | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 25th |
| 2017 | Dylan Stock | Sag Harbor '15 | Binghamton | Detroit Tigers | 25th |
| 2017 | Gavin Garay | Riverhead '16 | St. Petersburg | New York Mets | 26th |
| 2017 | Matt Seelinger | Montauk '16 | Farmingdale State | Pittsburgh Pirates | 28th |
| 2017 | Matt Hammonds | Southampton '14 | Sonoma State | Baltimore Orioles | 29th |
| 2017 | Mike Donadio | Riverhead '14 | St. John's | Miami Marlins | 30th |
| 2017 | Justin Jones | Shelter Island '14 | UNLV | Oakland Athletics | 34th |
| 2017 | Dan Jagiello | Riverhead '15 | LIU Post | Los Angeles Dodgers | 34th |
| 2017 | Josh Walker | Montauk '16 | New Haven | New York Mets | 37th |
| 2018 | Josiah Gray | Southampton '16 | Le Moyne | Cincinnati Reds | 2nd CBB |
| 2018 | Richard Palacios | North Fork '16 | Towson | Cleveland Indians | 3rd |
| 2018 | John Rooney | Southampton '16 | Hofstra | Los Angeles Dodgers | 3rd |
| 2018 | George Bell | Riverhead '17 | Connors State | San Francisco Giants | 13th |
| 2018 | Phil Capra | Montauk '16 | Wagner | New York Mets | 15th |
| 2018 | Brad Case | Montauk '16 | Rollins | Pittsburgh Pirates | 17th |
| 2018 | Evan Marquardt | Westhampton '15 | Ball State | Cincinnati Reds | 20th |
| 2018 | Reiss Knehr | Westhampton '16 | Fordham | San Diego Padres | 20th |
| 2018 | Erin Baldwin | Riverhead '15 | Samford | Arizona Diamondbacks | 20th |
| 2018 | John Valente | Montauk '15 | St. John's | Detroit Tigers | 21st |
| 2018 | Jamie Galazin | Westhampton '15, Montauk '16 | St. John's | Chicago Cubs | 22nd |
| 2018 | Ryan Ramiz | Southampton '15 | Seton Hall | Seattle Mariners | 23rd |
| 2018 | Bobby Honeyman | North Fork '15 | Stony Brook | Seattle Mariners | 29th |
| 2018 | Penn Murfee | North Fork '14 | Santa Clara | Seattle Mariners | 33rd |
| 2018 | Nick Matera | Sag Harbor '16 | Rutgers | Philadelphia Phillies | 34th |
| 2019 | Connor Lehmann | Southampton '17 | Saint Louis | San Diego Padres | 7th |
| 2019 | Luis Guerrero | Sag Harbor '18 | Miami Dade | Houston Astros | 8th |
| 2019 | Simon Whiteman | Southampton '17 | Yale | San Francisco Giants | 9th |
| 2019 | Sam Ryan | Sag Harbor '17 | Virginia Commonwealth | Toronto Blue Jays | 12th |
| 2019 | Nick Sogard | Shelter Island '17 | Loyola Marymount | Tampa Bay Rays | 12th |
| 2019 | Nick Morreale | Sag Harbor '17 | Georgetown | San Francisco Giants | 14th |
| 2019 | Kyle Martin | Riverhead '17 | Fordham | Baltimore Orioles | 15th |
| 2019 | Nick Grande | Long Island '17 | Stony Brook | Arizona Diamondbacks | 17th |
| 2019 | Ryan Smith | Montauk '16 | Princeton | Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | 18th |
| 2019 | Griffin Dey | Sag Harbor '16 | Yale | Detroit Tigers | 23rd |
| 2019 | Tyler Osik | Riverhead '15, Westhampton '17 | Central Florida | Chicago White Sox | 27th |
| 2019 | Mitch Calandra | Southampton '17 | Eckerd | Atlanta Braves | 30th |
| 2019 | Ed Baram | Southampton '16 | Adelphi | Oakland Athletics | 30th |
| 2019 | Max Smith | North Fork '16 | UNLV | Minnesota Twins | 31st |
| 2019 | Kumar Nambiar | North Fork '16 | Yale | Oakland Athletics | 34th |
| 2019 | Justin Washington | Sag Harbor '16 | Savannah State | Minnesota Twins | 35th |
| 2019 | Tom Archer | North Fork '16, '17 | Lynn | Chicago White Sox | 39th |
| 2019 | Logan Steenstra | Shelter Island '19 | Cowley College | Minnesota Twins | 40th |
| 2020 | Ryan Murphy | Sag Harbor '18 | Le Moyne | San Francisco Giants | 5th |
| 2021 | Carson Seymour | Southampton '18 | Kansas State | New York Mets | 6th |
| 2021 | Justice Thompson | Southampton '19 | North Carolina | Cincinnati Reds | 6th |
| 2021 | Parker Bates | North Fork '17 | Louisiana Tech | Kansas City Royals | 9th |
| 2021 | Peter Matt | North Fork '17 | Duke | Chicago Cubs | 10th |
| 2021 | River Town | Sag Harbor '19 | Dallas Baptist | Kansas City Royals | 15th |
| 2021 | Jimmy Joyce | Southampton '18 | Hofstra | Seattle Mariners | 16th |
| 2022 | Mario Camilletti | Southampton '18 | Central Michigan | Chicago White Sox | 8th |
| 2022 | Joe Stewart | Westhampton '19 | Michigan | Los Angeles Angels | 9th |
| 2022 | Javier Vaz | North Fork '19 | Vanderbilt | Kansas City Royals | 15th |
| 2022 | Bryce Willits | Riverhead '19 | UC Santa Barbara | Chicago White Sox | 18th |
| 2023 | Cory Wall | Southampton '19 | William & Mary | Atlanta Braves | 8th |
| 2023 | Brian Hendry | Riverhead '19 | Oklahoma State | New York Yankees | 10th |
| 2023 | Matt Jachec | Southampton '21 | Indiana State | Cleveland Guardians | 18th |
| 2024 | Sean Keys | Westhampton '22, '23 | Bucknell | Toronto Blue Jays | 4th |
| 2024 | Justin Sinibaldi | Sag Harbor '21 | Rutgers | Chicago White Sox | 14th |
